Planning a Home Remodel? What to Know About Insurance
Takeaways
- A standard homeowners policy may not fully cover a home under major renovation, so coverage is worth reviewing before the first contract is signed and again whenever the project changes.
- If a covered loss stalls the work, loan interest and other soft costs keep running. Knowing which ones your policy picks up tells you how large a contingency reserve to hold.
- Most remodels return well under their cost at resale. An upscale kitchen remodel recoups about 36% of its cost, according to the 2025 Cost vs. Value Report. That can still be the right call when you know what you’re paying for.
- Remodel decisions hold up better when insurance, financing and long-term housing plans are looked at together, before contracts are signed.
Most homeowners assume their policy covers the house no matter what’s happening inside it. Once a major remodel or custom build begins, that assumption can stop holding.
Construction brings contractors, stored materials, open walls and sometimes months of vacancy, and each can change what a standard policy will pay for. If you’re planning a home remodel, the insurance questions are best settled before the first contract is signed, while there’s still time to close a gap.
Then come the money questions, including one many families skip: what would you get back if you had to sell in 10 months? A Personal CFO approach looks at the coverage and the plan together. We start with insurance and then turn to the financial side.
What your homeowners policy may not cover during a remodel
Construction changes your exposure. Crews are on the property and materials sit on site. Parts of the house may also be open to the weather, or vacant for months if the family moves out. A standard homeowners policy may not fully cover a home under major renovation or the work in progress, and coverage set before the work began may not fit the project as its budget and timeline grow. Course-of-construction coverage, often called builder’s risk, is designed for this situation, and construction contracts or loan documents sometimes require it.
The questions below are best taken to your insurance professional before the construction contract and loan documents are final, with both documents and the project budget on hand. A Personal CFO does not provide insurance advice, but can recognize when a project calls for specialist input and help start that conversation early.
Your policy and the work in progress
Some policies treat a vacant home differently from an occupied one, which matters if you move out during construction.
- Does my current policy cover the house while it’s under major renovation, and does that change if we move out?
- Do I need a builder’s risk policy or an endorsement, and does my contract or lender require one?
- Does replacement-cost coverage apply to both the existing structure and the work in progress?
- Are materials stored on site or in transit covered?
If the project stalls
Delays and overruns are common on large projects, and clients often underestimate both. If a fire or storm halts the work, construction-loan interest, property taxes and permit fees keep running while the project sits, on top of the repairs. Some policies cover part of these soft costs and others leave them with the homeowner.
- If a covered loss delays the project, which soft costs are covered and which are mine?
Your coverage and your builder’s
Your coverage and your contractor’s are meant to work together, but the details sit in documents many homeowners never read closely. Contract terms such as additional-insured status or a waiver of subrogation can change who pays when something goes wrong. Your insurance professional and attorney are the right people to review them before you sign.
- How does my coverage interact with my contractor’s, and what do the contract’s insurance requirements mean for me?
Thinking through the insurance side of a remodel? Let’s talk about how it fits your complete financial picture. Schedule an intro call.
Liability, resilience and your wider wealth plan
A remodel brings new people onto your property and new contracts into your life. For families whose home holds a large share of their wealth, it’s a good time to review liability limits and umbrella insurance and to check for other common insurance gaps. It’s also a natural point to decide how much risk to keep and how much to transfer to an insurer.
- Are my liability and umbrella limits still right with crews on the property?
With the walls open, a remodel is a rare chance to address wildfire, wind or earthquake risk, or sewer backups. In one study of home sales in coastal Alabama, homes built to the FORTIFIED standard sold for roughly 7% more than comparable homes, and the National Institute of Building Sciences reports insurance premiums 16% to 40% lower for FORTIFIED homes there, where state law requires insurers to discount the wind portion of the premium for homes built to the standard. Both findings come from a hurricane-exposed market with a mandated discount and won’t carry over to every region, so confirm any expected insurance benefit with your insurer. With property insurance premiums rising in many regions, staying insurable on good terms has become part of what a home is worth.
- Would any resilience upgrade we’re considering affect my premium or insurability?
Budgets and scope often change mid-build, so coverage needs more than one look.
- At which points during the project should we review coverage again?
Planning a home remodel: The financial questions behind the insurance ones
Coverage protects what you’re putting into the house. The planning questions are about whether the project fits everything else that money is meant to do.
Is a remodel an investment? What kitchen remodel ROI data shows
One question we ask clients before they call a remodel an investment: is this a $100,000 investment, or a $100,000 purchase that happens to raise the home’s value? National averages from the 2025 Cost vs. Value Report suggest the answer is usually the second:
- Major kitchen remodel, upscale: about $164,000 average cost, about 36% recouped at resale
- Bath remodel, upscale: about $82,000 average cost, about 42% recouped at resale
Applied to the kitchen figure, $100,000 of spending might add roughly $36,000 at resale. (This is a hypothetical illustration based on national averages, not a projection for any home. What a remodel adds at resale depends on the home and its local market when it sells, and it can be less than these averages.) Most housing-related remodels don’t produce a positive return, and that’s OK. If the goal is a kitchen your family gathers in or a home you can stay in as you age, the value shows up somewhere other than the appraisal.
Where the money comes from
A significant remodel pulls assets that were working toward other goals, such as retirement, a future downsizing or long-term care, and reallocates them into the home. As budgets rise mid-build, more of the family’s wealth ends up concentrated in a single asset. If the home’s equity is meant to fund retirement, or serve as the backup plan for long-term care, the question is whether that’s still realistic once the money has gone into the walls.
Remodel spending can also matter at tax time. Under IRS rules, the cost of qualifying improvements is added to your home’s cost basis, which can reduce the taxable gain on a sale. That’s relevant if your gain could exceed the home-sale exclusion of $250,000 ($500,000 for married couples filing jointly). Our guide to the 2-out-of-5-year rule explains how that exclusion works, and there are other ways to reduce capital gains tax on real estate if the gain is larger.
Liquidity and the contingency reserve
Two liquidity mistakes come up again and again. The first is planning to fund the project by selling investments as invoices arrive. Recency bias makes it easy to underestimate how long stocks can go through stretches of weak returns, and sharp drops within a single year are more routine than many investors remember (see the normalcy of volatility). If markets are down when the contractor needs paying, you may end up selling at a loss. The second mistake runs the other way: letting too much money sit in low- or non-interest-bearing accounts just in case, where it carries a hidden cost in growth it never earns.
One way to think about it: hold the project budget, plus a contingency reserve sized to the soft costs your policy won’t cover, in cash or short-term instruments, and keep the rest invested for the goals it was built for. It also helps to agree in advance on what would prompt a step back, such as an overrun past a set amount, so the family revisits the project on purpose instead of funding the next invoice by default.
Remodel or move?
Renovating isn’t automatically the best answer. A side-by-side comparison with relocating makes sense whenever the remodel cost becomes significant, and any time the plan involves moving out during construction and moving back in. Moving carries its own frictional costs. Agent commissions and sale preparation add up quickly, and taxes on the gain can follow. A new mortgage may also come at a meaningfully higher rate than one taken out five to ten years ago. In some situations, though, relocating offers more certainty about timing and cost than a long remodel can, and financing a long build can become complex and costly as loan draws and extensions pile up. If a move is on the table, the same liquidity questions apply to how much to put down on the next home.
Questions to answer before you commit
- How does this project tie into your values, and what do you want the home to make possible for your family?
- How long do you expect to live in the remodeled home?
- Is this an investment, or a purchase that happens to raise the home’s value?
- If the home’s equity is part of your retirement or long-term care plan, is that still realistic after the project?
- How much would you recoup if you sold in 10 to 20 years?
- How much would you recoup if you were forced to sell in 10 months?
The last question is the hardest to answer honestly. A job change, a health event or a shift in family plans can force a sale on someone else’s timeline. At that point, the gap between what the project cost and what a buyer will pay is the number that matters.
Bringing the right team in early
On a large project, the builder, lender, insurance professional, attorney and CPA each see part of the picture. The family lives with the combined result of decisions made separately.
A Personal CFO is often the first professional to hear that a project is being considered, either in a planning conversation or through a request to move money for a deposit. That timing is useful. We work alongside your insurance professional and contractor, making sure the right conversations happen before key decisions are final and that everyone is working from the same assumptions. That coordination matters most before contracts are signed and financing is chosen, and again whenever the scope changes. One more check near completion helps make sure coverage reflects the finished home’s new value. Our overview of the professionals on your financial team covers who else may belong in that room.
A major remodel or custom build touches nearly every part of a financial plan at once. In our experience, the projects that go best are the ones where insurance, financing, construction and planning decisions are considered together, early enough to change the result.
Frequently asked questions
Does homeowners insurance cover a remodel?
Not always. A standard homeowners policy may not fully cover a home under major renovation, the work in progress or materials stored on site, and some policies treat a vacant home differently. Depending on the project, a builder’s risk policy or an endorsement may be needed. An insurance professional can review contract and loan requirements before work begins.
What is builder’s risk insurance?
Builder’s risk, also called course-of-construction coverage, is designed for homes being built or significantly renovated. Depending on the policy, it may address materials, soft costs, delays and lender interests that a standard homeowners policy may not cover. Construction contracts or loan documents sometimes require it, so reviewing them before work begins is worthwhile.
Does a kitchen remodel pay for itself when you sell?
Usually not. According to the 2025 Cost vs. Value Report, an upscale major kitchen remodel recouped about 36% of its cost at resale nationally. Results vary by market. Many homeowners remodel anyway because they value how they’ll live in the home more than the resale number.
Do home improvements reduce taxes when you sell your home?
They can. IRS rules let you add the cost of qualifying improvements to your home’s basis, which reduces the taxable gain when you sell. This matters most if your gain could exceed the home-sale exclusion of $250,000, or $500,000 for married couples filing jointly. A tax professional can confirm how the rules apply.
Is it better to remodel or move?
It depends on the size of the project and how long you plan to stay. Moving brings commissions and preparation costs, and possibly taxes on the gain. A new mortgage may also carry a higher rate than your current one. Any remodel large enough to require moving out and back in calls for a side-by-side comparison with a move.
About the Author: Hinnah Daryani, CFP®, Lead Advisor, serves clients as a fiduciary. She believes a financial plan should be measured by the freedom it gives people to do what fulfills them, with investment returns as one part of that picture. She works closely with clients to understand what they want their money to make possible, including major decisions like a remodel or a new home.
Ready to explore how a remodel or custom build fits into your complete financial picture? Our Personal CFO approach helps you align your money with what matters most. Schedule an intro call.
Standard Disclosure: Please remember that past performance may not be indicative of future results. Different types of investments involve varying degrees of risk. Brighton Jones, LLC is neither a law firm nor a certified public accounting firm and no portion of the blog content should be construed as legal or accounting advice. To the extent that you have any questions regarding the applicability of any specific issue discussed above to your individual situation, you are encouraged to consult with the professional advisor of your choosing.
Sources: Journal of Light Construction, 2025 Cost vs. Value Report (national averages). IRS Publication 523, Selling Your Home (2025 returns). Hollans, Awondo, Powell and Wade, “Estimating the Effect of Fortified Home Construction on Home Resale Value”. National Institute of Building Sciences, resilience incentives summary.